16-17 OCTOBER, 2001

MisiakRoger-2.jpg (9672 bytes)Issues about forest health engaged an audience for two days on 16 and 17 October in the Newberry area at the 2001 Fall Meeting of the Michigan SAF. About 100 people attended the combined indoor and outdoor program, arranged by Bob Heyd, Rich Trevillian, and Les Homan.

Michigan SAF Chair, Roger Misiak, kicked off the program with opening comments.

Frank Sapio, Michigan DNR, provided an overview of forest health monitoring programs in the state. He highlighted a number of cooperative efforts with other agencies and previewed current and upcoming technology designed to aid in the evaluation of forest health.

Frank focused on the following elements of statewide forest health monitoring.DNRimage.jpg (7455 bytes)

1. Integrated Pest Management (IPM).
2. Interagency efforts.
3. Growing forest exotics concern.
4. New and developing technologies (i.e. IFMAP, digital aerial sketch-mapping).
5. New DNR on-line reporting system. [DNR Forest Health Page]

McCulloughDeb-1.jpg (8170 bytes)Deb McCullough, Michigan State University, spoke about an impending outbreak of jack pine budworm (Choristoneura pinus), based on 2001 mortality in the Raco Plains area of the eastern Upper Peninsula. The jack pine budworm is part of our native system and we are due for another cyclical high within the next couple years.

BBD-scale2.jpg (15254 bytes)Beech bark disease (BBD) was first discovered in Michigan in 1999, although it has likely been here for at least a decade. Distribution maps are updated frequently as observation reports are submitted. BBD is combination of an exotic scale insect (Cryptococcus fagisuga) and at least two species of Nectria canker, one native (Nectria galligena) and one exotic (Nectria coccinea var. faginata). Martin MacKenzie, U.S. Forest Service from Morgantown, West Virginia, presented a case study of the BBD in North America. The disease has killed large volumes of beech across New England and eastern states. It’s a slow-acting disease but will result in significant beech volume loss in Michigan over the next decade or so. MSU produced an excellent publication which is also available on the MSAF website (

Sudden oak death (SOD) and the hemlock woolly adelgid are two exotics that are serious pests in other parts of North America but have yet to reach Michigan.

StorerAndrew-1.jpg (8339 bytes)Sudden oak death is a fungus (Phytophthora ramorum) that has killed a range of woody species along the California coast. The fungus may have been introduced with rhododendron imports from Europe, but the disease is so new that much remains to be learned. The latest information can be obtained from the website (

The SOD upshot for Michigan is that the western bigleaf maple (Acer macrophyllum) has just been added to the susceptibility list. Acer spp. comprise nearly 30 percent of Michigan’s timberland volume. Threats to the maple resource are serious should our native maples prove to be susceptible. Andrew Storer, Michigan Technological University, provided background and current information about the new disease. Andrew is a recent addition to the Michigan forestry community, educated in England and comes our way via California.

HWA.jpg (19240 bytes)The hemlock woolly adelgid (HWA) (Adelges tsugae) is an exotic insect from Europe that was introduced to North America around 1927. Eastern hemlock (Tsuga canadensis) across New England and the northern Appalachians has suffered extensive mortality. HWA is not yet in Michigan, although two cases of infected nursery stock have been intercepted and treated. John Hill of the Michigan Department of Agriculture explained the quarantine laws protecting Michigan from early introduction, but it appears the insect will eventually reach Michigan via natural vectors. News about the HWA can be found on the website (, included biology, photos, distribution maps, and details on the Michigan quarantine.

HeydBob-1.jpg (7707 bytes)Bob Heyd, Michigan DNR, provided a review of some the major pest events of 2001.  Forest tent caterpillar (Malacosoma disstria) defoliated tree across large acreages of the Upper Peninsula and populations may increase in the Lower Peninsula in 2002.  Jack pine budworm is on the move in the eastern U.P.  Oak wilt (Ceratocystis fagacearum) continues to advance across the Lower Peninsula and eradication efforts are underway in the southern U.P.  Larch casebearer (Coleophora laricella) outbreaks in tamarack continue throughout the state.

Frank.jpg (12656 bytes)The evening featured a chicken and ribs buffet catered by Timber Charlie’s of Newberry, followed by the Foresters Fund Raffle and an Awards Program. Special thanks to Mike Elenz, Frank Laurence, Todd Green, and Mike Lanasa.


Moose.jpg (14597 bytes)A great program on Michigan moose was provided by Terry Minzey, of the Michigan DNR. Terry reviewed the species taxonomy, history, biology, and current status. The focus for foresters is a reminder of our effect on habitat conditions across our forests and how dependent wildlife are on what we do, or don’t do. Continuing to blend habitat considerations into our forest management, especially at the landscape level, is critical to the welfare of Michigan wildlife and overall forest health.



FTCeggmass.jpg (12487 bytes)On Wednesday, a field tour was arranged to see, first-hand, some of the concerns in the forest.

The tour began with a lesson in how to count forest tent caterpillar egg masses to predict the potential severity of a next season outbreak. Several aspen should be felled to reach the crowns. If a half-dozen egg masses can be spotted in five minutes, the next summer is likely to witness significant defoliation.

Phellinus-1.jpg (15922 bytes)The group used the same felled trees to see the effect of white trunk rot (Phellinus tremulae) in the aspen. A Minnesota study by Jones & Ostry (Northern Journal of Applied Forestry, March 1998) shows that past rule-of-thumb estimates based on conk appearance underestimated trunk rot by 38 percent. The number of conks are predictive of volume loss from 2-32 percent. The average decay column extended five feet below the lowest conk and eight feet above the upper conk.

BBD-trunk.jpg (31764 bytes)The bus and truck caravan proceeded to Bass Lake Campground, the first site that beech bark disease was observed in the U.P. Excellent examples of the scale populations and tar-spot and fruiting bodies of Nectria spp. were seen. Genetic resistance is a key to maintaining beech in the forests of Michigan. Identification of possible resistant trees was demonstrated by Shelter Bay foresters on properties they manage.

Budworm.jpg (16424 bytes)



The last scheduled stop was a jack pine stand near Tahquamenon Falls State Park that was partially defoliated by the jack pine budworm the summer of 2001.  Most of the dead needles had been washed off by recent rains, but thin crowns and pupal cases could be observed.


A Few Links to Forest Health / Insect & Disease Information

Beech Bark Disease (
Sudden Oak Death (
Hemlock Woolly Adelgid (
Asian Long-horned Beetle (
Pine Shoot Beetle (
MDNR Forest Health (,1607,7-153-30301_30505_30830---,00.html)
U.S. Forest Insect & Disease Leaflets (FIDLs) (
MSU "CAT" Alerts - Landscape Edition (
Michigan Invasive Plant Council (

Michigan SAF Home Page

This website is maintained by Bill Cook, Michigan State University Extension Forest in the Upper Peninsula.  Comments, questions, and suggestions are gratefully accepted. 

Last update of this page was 08 July 2003 .  21 September, 2005





This site is hosted by School of Forest Resources and Environmental Science at Michigan Technological University.

Michigan Tech